
You were hurt in a car accident. The insurance company called. They were pleasant, concerned and surprisingly efficient. Now there is a settlement offer sitting in front of you.
It may even seem like pretty good money.
Before you start shopping for a boat, there is one question worth asking: **Why is an insurance company so eager to give me money?**
Insurance companies do not make early settlement offers because they suddenly became charitable organizations. They settle claims because resolving claims is their business, and resolving a claim early can limit what they ultimately have to pay.
That doesn’t automatically mean an early settlement offer is unfair. It does mean you should understand what you are giving up before you accept it.
Why Would an Insurance Company Offer a Quick Settlement?
Imagine you own something that might ultimately cost you $100,000, but there is a chance you can buy your way out of the problem today for $15,000.
You would probably at least try.
Insurance companies evaluate claims for a living. When an adjuster makes an early offer, the company may already have enough information to know its insured was responsible for the accident.
What it may not know yet is how badly you were hurt.
Neither may you.
Some injuries resolve quickly. Others don’t. A sore back becomes a herniated disc. Physical therapy doesn’t work. An orthopedic surgeon recommends injections or surgery. Someone who expected to miss three days of work misses three months.
Once you settle your personal injury claim and sign a release, you generally do not get to reopen negotiations because your injury turned out to be worse than you thought.
The insurance company’s uncertainty becomes your risk.
Don’t Settle Before You Understand Your Injuries
One of the biggest mistakes an injured person can make is valuing a claim before the medical picture is clear.
A personal injury claim can include much more than the emergency room bill sitting on your kitchen counter.
Depending on the case, damages may include:
– Past and future medical expenses
– Lost wages
– Loss of future earning capacity
– Pain and suffering
– Disability or permanent impairment
– Loss of enjoyment of life
– Other losses caused by the injury
You cannot intelligently evaluate an offer if you don’t yet know what the accident is going to cost you.
I wouldn’t sell a house before finding out whether it had three bedrooms or six. Your personal injury claim deserves at least the same level of investigation.
The First Offer Is Not a Verdict
People sometimes assume an insurance company’s offer represents some official calculation of what their case is worth.
It doesn’t.
It is an offer.
The adjuster works for the insurance company, not for you. Their job is to evaluate the company’s exposure and resolve claims within parameters established by the insurer.
That is not sinister. It is simply important to remember who is sitting on which side of the table.
An insurance adjuster may tell you an offer is reasonable. They may tell you it reflects the medical bills they have received. They may tell you it is the most they can offer.
None of those statements turns the offer into the value of your case.
What Is My Car Accident Case Actually Worth?
This is where people become frustrated with lawyers because the correct answer is usually: **it depends.**
I know. Very helpful.
But personal injury cases are called personal injury cases for a reason. Two people can suffer what appears to be the same injury and have dramatically different claims.
A broken wrist may be an inconvenience to someone who works at a desk. The same injury could threaten the livelihood of a surgeon, mechanic or professional musician.
The value of a Missouri car accident claim can depend on the severity and permanence of the injury, medical treatment, lost income, future limitations, the facts of the collision, available insurance coverage, the credibility of the witnesses and dozens of other factors.
There is no legitimate online calculator that can digest all of that and spit out the value of your case.
What Happens When I Accept a Settlement?
This is the part that deserves your attention.
A personal injury settlement normally requires you to sign a release resolving the claim. Once the claim is finally settled and released, you generally cannot return months later and ask for additional money because you discovered you need more treatment.
The $10,000 that looked attractive three weeks after an accident looks considerably less attractive when surgery costs many times that amount.
Before accepting a settlement, you should understand:
– The full extent of your injuries
– Whether additional medical treatment is likely
– How much work you have lost or may lose
– Whether your injuries will cause permanent limitations
– What insurance coverage is available
– What claims you are releasing
A settlement should resolve the problem. It should not create a new one.
Do I Need a Lawyer Before Accepting a Car Accident Settlement?
Not every scratched bumper requires a personal injury lawyer.
If nobody was injured and the dispute is simply about repairing a vehicle, hiring an attorney may not make sense.
But if you suffered a meaningful injury, are still receiving treatment, missed substantial work, have permanent symptoms, face disputed fault or simply don’t understand whether an offer fairly compensates you, it is worth talking to an experienced car accident lawyer before signing anything.
A consultation does not obligate you to file a lawsuit.
Sometimes the most useful thing a lawyer can tell you is that you can handle the claim yourself.
Other times, that conversation prevents you from signing away a valuable claim for a fraction of what it is worth.
Before You Say Yes, Know What You’re Saying Yes To
There is nothing wrong with settling a car accident claim. Most personal injury cases resolve without a jury ever hearing them.
The question isn’t whether you should settle.
The question is whether you should settle **for that amount, at that time and under those circumstances.**
If you were injured in a car accident in St. Louis or elsewhere in Missouri and have received a settlement offer, The S.E. Farris Law Firm can help you understand what the offer means before you decide whether to accept it.
Because the best time to find out that an insurance company offered too little is before you sign the release.
