
Two people are involved in separate car accidents. Both suffer broken legs. Both require surgery. Both spend six weeks recovering.
Their personal injury cases should be worth about the same amount, right?
Not necessarily. In fact, the difference could be enormous.
One person might recover completely and return to normal life. The other might never be able to perform the job they spent 20 years learning to do.
Same bone. Same fracture. Very different consequences.
This is one reason I get suspicious when someone tells me they can calculate the value of a personal injury case using a computer program and a few medical bills.
If it were that simple, lawyers could be replaced by calculators.
Some people might consider that progress.
Personal Injury Cases Are About People, Not Just Injuries
The phrase personal injury is not an accident.
A personal injury claim is about how an injury affects a particular person, under particular circumstances, because of a particular event.
Consider two people who suffer identical hand injuries.
One is an accountant who can return to work after a few weeks. The other is a concert pianist whose career depends on extraordinary precision and dexterity.
The injury may look identical on an X-ray.
Its consequences are not.
That doesn’t automatically mean one person deserves more compensation than the other. It means evaluating the damages requires understanding the individual, not merely identifying the diagnosis.
Medical Bills Don’t Tell the Whole Story
People frequently ask whether their case is worth three times their medical bills, five times their medical bills or some other mysterious multiple.
There was a time when lawyers and insurance adjusters used formulas as rough negotiating tools.
But a formula cannot tell you whether someone will recover completely, need another operation or spend the rest of their life dealing with chronic pain.
Medical expenses are important evidence. They help establish the treatment required and the financial consequences of an injury.
They are not the entire case.
A person with relatively modest medical expenses may experience substantial permanent limitations. Someone else may incur enormous medical bills but ultimately recover without lasting impairment.
Both situations require careful evaluation.
How Lost Income Changes the Value of a Claim
An injury can affect more than the paycheck you missed last Friday.
Some people return to their jobs without difficulty. Others must reduce their hours, change careers or stop working altogether.
Suppose a construction worker suffers a serious back injury in a St. Louis car accident.
After treatment, the worker can walk, drive and handle ordinary household activities. From a distance, the recovery looks pretty good.
But the worker can no longer lift heavy materials, climb ladders or perform the physical tasks the job requires.
That injury may affect decades of future earnings.
Now imagine someone with the same diagnosis whose employment and earning capacity are unaffected.
The medical condition may be similar. The economic damages may be dramatically different.
And proving future lost earning capacity often requires much more than handing an insurance adjuster a few pay stubs.
The Facts of the Accident Matter, Too
How the injury occurred is also important.
A driver who momentarily misjudges the distance between two vehicles presents different circumstances from someone who was driving drunk, racing through a residential neighborhood or staring at a phone.
In Missouri, the facts can affect liability, comparative fault and, in appropriate cases, whether punitive damages are legally available.
Missouri follows a pure comparative fault system in ordinary negligence cases. If an injured person shares responsibility for an accident, their compensatory recovery may be reduced by their percentage of fault.
For example, if damages are assessed at $200,000 and the injured person is found 25% responsible, the recovery would generally be reduced to $150,000.
That’s a substantial difference, and it has nothing to do with the diagnosis.
Credibility and Evidence Can Change Everything
Two cases may involve identical injuries but very different evidence.
One collision was captured by a traffic camera. The driver admitted fault. Witnesses agree about what happened.
In the other, the drivers give conflicting accounts, the witnesses disagree and the physical evidence is inconclusive.
Guess which case may be easier to prove?
The same is true of damages.
Medical records, employment records, photographs, expert opinions and credible testimony can help demonstrate how an injury changed someone’s life.
A good personal injury lawyer doesn’t simply collect bills.
The lawyer builds the evidence necessary to explain the injury and its consequences.
Insurance Coverage Can Affect What Is Recoverable
There is another uncomfortable reality.
The legal value of a case and the amount that can realistically be recovered are not always the same.
A seriously injured person may have substantial damages, but the responsible party may carry limited liability insurance and have few collectible assets.
Another case may involve significantly more available insurance coverage.
This doesn’t change what the injury cost the person. It can change the practical options for obtaining compensation.
Identifying available insurance policies and other potential sources of recovery is an important part of evaluating a Missouri personal injury claim.
So What Is My Personal Injury Case Worth?
The answer requires examining the person, the injury, the evidence, the law and the available coverage.
It requires understanding what happened before the accident, what changed afterward and what the future may look like.
That takes time, investigation and judgment.
It is not something a settlement calculator can reliably determine after asking for your ZIP code and the amount of your emergency room bill.
At The S.E. Farris Law Firm, we represent people injured in car accidents and other incidents throughout St. Louis and Missouri.
If you’ve been injured because of someone else’s negligence, we can help evaluate the circumstances of your case and the damages you may be entitled to pursue.
Because no two people are exactly alike.
Their personal injury cases shouldn’t be treated as though they are, either.
